A hero’s life overshadowed


The premiere of Benjamin Britten’s opera The Turn of the Screw at the Teatro la Fenice, Venice in 1954 was one of the events that changed the direction of twentieth century music. The photograph above was taken in Venice at the time of the premiere and shows Britten with some of those who helped reshape post-war music. Directly across from the composer is Peter Diamand, who was a co-founder and general manager of the Holland Festival, director of the Edinburgh Festival, director of the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra and artistic adviser to the Orchestre de Paris. On Diamand’s right is an exceptional musician whose reputation, like their face in this photo, has been overshadowed by the brilliant circle in which they moved. For the moment let’s just call that person our incognito hero, or IH for short.

Our incognito hero came from a musical family and studied at a leading music conservatory. In 1930 a scholarship allowed the adventurous IH to travel and study music in the, then, political tinder-boxes of Austria, Germany, Holland and Hungary, as well as investigating stone circles in Sweden and Greek temples in Sicily by way of relaxation. Folk and early music were life-long passions, but a residency in Switzerland in 1939 to study the music of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries was cut short by the outbreak of war.

As the fascist blight spread our incognito hero made a truly valuable contribution by serving on the Bloomsbury House Committee refugee committee, which helped many exiled musicians from Germany and Austria start new lives and careers. IH then went on to play an important role in supporting amateur music in wartime Britain. After the war our hero continued to travel in Europe and in 1951 ventured further afield, spending two months studying the folk music of India and teaching at Rabindrath Tagore’s Santiniketan University in West Bengal. This was a decade before an Indian connection became an essential entry on the CV of ambitious contemporary composers.

It was in the role of musical animateur that our hero really made an impact. From 1942 to 1951 IH lived and worked in the pioneering creative community at Dartington Hall in Devon that later played host to Pierre Boulez, Bruno Maderna and Karlheinz Stockhausen. From 1943 IH held the influential position of director of music at Dartington. Music critic and broadcaster John Amis described our hero’s contribution there as follows:

Some of the best lectures in the early years came from IH who could talk about the basic elements, ‘Rhythm’ or ‘Melody’, in such a way as not only to instruct but to touch you by (their) exposition of the simple facts of musical life. I have seen Paul Hindemith and Artur Schnabel in IH’s audience jingling pennies in their handkerchiefs to imitate percussion instruments, and loving it.

In 1952 Benjamin Britten invited our incognito hero to Aldeburgh to work as his music assistant, and IH’s work included orchestrating Britten’s Rejoice in the Lamb for the 1952 Aldeburgh Festival. IH held the influential position of the artistic director of the Aldeburgh Festival for the 1956 and 1957 seasons and, while in Suffolk, wrote books on Purcell, Byrd, Bach and Britten. In 1964 our hero left Aldeburgh to concentrate on editing and promoting the music of a famous father who had died thirty years earlier. He was Gustav Holst, and our incognito hero is, of course, Imogen Holst, who is seen, out of the shadows, below.


Imogen Host is remembered today mainly for her contribution at Aldeburgh, and for her work championing her father’s music. But she was also a very talented composer. Her compositions included a 1928 Phantasy Quartet which dates from her time as a student the Royal Academy of Music in London. This lyrical quartet shows the influence of one of her teachers, Ralph Vaughan Williams, and is a noteworthy example of English Pastoralism. But the quartet is untypical of her output and it would be a pity if it branded Imogen Holst as a Classic FM composer. The 1930 Sonata for Violin and Cello was written in Vienna and its confident use of dissonance marks her emergence as a contemporary voice. The sinewy String Trio No. 1 was written in 1944 for the Dartington Trio and uses a bitonal effect with the two violins ganging up on the usual victim, the viola.

After a fallow period while at Aldeburgh, Imogen Holst returned to composing in the 1960s. Her output included the three short studies for solo cello on tunes from the Fitzwilliam Virginal Book titled The Fall of the Leaf which have gained some acceptance as repertory pieces, and her 1968 Duo for Viola and Piano. The latter reflects the turbulence of its year of composition and experiments with twelve-tone techniques. In 1982, two years before her death, Imogen Holst composed her valedictory String Quintet, a magnificent work that, sadly, has yet to take its rightful place in the chamber repertoire.

Below are two striking photo portraits of Imogen Holst. She never married, but the early portrait shows her as a striking beauty. If I have achieved anything in this article, it is, I hope, to make you want to hear more of this little-known composer’s music. Now here is the very good news. All the works I have described are recorded for the first time on a new CD of Imogen Holst’s String Chamber Music played with outstanding commitment and technical fluency by Court Lane Music and issued on the ensembles own record label.

This is quite outstanding music which mirrors contemporary trends while retaining a unique voice. If the composer had been a male emigrée from Central Europe who spent their sunset years on the campus of a liberal arts college, I am sure this story would read very differently. But, even in 2008, the importance of geography, gender and celebrity culture mean this important new release has attracted only minimal attention. But you can rectify that by buying Imogen Holst’s String Chamber Music as an MP3 download or CD here. ImHo this is music that really must be listened to with innocent ears.


Sources and suggested further reading:
- Imogen Holst - A Life in Music edited by Christopher Grogan (Boydell & Brewer ISBN 9781843832966)
- The Pandora Guide to Women Composers by Sophie Fuller (Pandora ISBN 0044409362)
- Benjamin Britten, Pictures from a Life 1913-1976 compiled by Donald Mitchell & John Evans (Faber ISBN 0571115705 OP)
- Gustav Holst, A Biography by Imogen Holst (Faber ISBN 9780571241996)
- Amiscellany - My Life, My Music by John Amis (Faber ISBN 0571139698 OP)
- Gustav Holst, links to Hindu Mysticism from International Vegetarian Union

- For a fresh view on Gustav Holst’s most familiar work try York 2 playing the four hand piano reduction of The Planets.
- Gustav Holst’s Eastern influenced works include his one-act opera Savitri and Choral Hymns from the Rig Veda; the latter predated the Manhattan Project by thirty years.

Other Overgrown Path portraits of women in music include:
- Elisabeth Lutyens
- Elizabeth Maconchy
- Antonia Brico
- Ray Lev
- Wanda Landowska

Header photos credit Erich Auerbach, footer is from CD sleeve. Full listing of personalities in the header image from left to right are Marion Harewood, Peter Diamand, Imogen Holst, Lord Harewood, Anthony Gishford, Mrs Stein, Mrs Diamand (back to camera) and Britten. The two men behind Britten are unidentified but are probably Basil Douglas and Erwin Stein. Imogen Holst’s String Chamber Music supplied by Court Lane Music in response to request from On An Overgrown Path. All books purchased at retail with exception of Imogen Holst - A Life in Music and Gustv Holst, A Biography, which were borrowed from Norfolk Library Services. Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

This is the future of classical music


A classical chamber orchestra on the opening night of the London Jazz Festival with a Tunisian oud player? Purists on every side must have been steaming from all orifices. But this is the future of music. And it works, as this exhilarating fusion showed.

Nothing demonstrated that better than Arvo Pärt’s 1977 minimalist classic, Fratres. It opened the concert, played “straight” by the excellent strings of the Britten Sinfonia under Joanna MacGregor’s (below) direction, with its elegiac refrain rising and falling over a drone like a sombre ritual. Then, at the end, it was repeated as an encore - but with a difference. This time the great Dhafer Youssef (above) and the virtuoso percussionist Satoshi Takeishi added a subtle, shadowy patina of Arabic cries and whispers. It was as if the ancestral Estonian modes summoned by Pärt in Northern Europe had stirred strange, kindred echoes in North Africa. Pure musical magic.

And it wasn’t the only heartstoppingly beautiful moment in this “East meets West meets North meets South” programme. Youssef’s own pieces - gentle-spirited, syncopated improvisations in sophisticated metres, showcasing his stunningly pure voice (electronically enhanced with overlapping echoes), his shofar-like falsetto, and dextrous fingerwork on his Arabic lute - gained a dimension, sonically and expressively, when accompanied by the strings. Meanwhile, Takeishi, squatting beside his exotic drums and cymbals, supplied deft and supple solos, as did the ubiquitous jazz bassist Peter Herbert. And the Britten Sinfonia brought to the party some cool culture-hopping of its own. With MacGregor at the piano and Jacqueline Shave supplying fleet-fingered fiddle solos, it played three of MacGregor’s exuberant arrangements of songs by the renowned Romanian gypsy singer Gabi Lunca.

Then Shave led two evocative pieces by Bartók. The Burletta from the Sixth Quartet was properly savage. But Pe Loc from the Romanian Folk Dances was the real show- stopper, with Youssef’s voice and Takeishi’s brushed drums again adding a mysterious and mystical subtext. No, Bartók didn’t write it like that. But yes, that dedicated follower of folk fashion would have loved the intrusion.

Richard Morrison in The Times gives the Britten Sinfonia concert at the London Jazz Festival a well-deserved five stars. I don’t normally reblog complete reviews. But this could be the end of Western art music.


Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

Classical music community 1 - Philistines 0


A news story, which has just broken in Holland, makes very sweet reading indeed. Here is a free translation:

Dutch Culture Minister halts Concertzender closure

DEN HAAG 17 NOV 17.35h - Culture Minister Ronald Plasterk has approached the Board of Directors of the Dutch Public Broadcasting System (NPO) to insist that classical internet station Concertzender remain on-air. This promise was made by the Minister in response to questions posed to him by Parliament Member Boris van der Ham (party D66).

Concertzender heard last week that the NPO would terminate its financial support as of January 1st. “I am ready to enter into discussion with the Board of Directors to figure out how the valuable contributions of Concertzender to the Dutch music culture can be given an appropriate place in a new structure,” says Plasterk.

Van der Ham had asked Plasterk for clarification regarding the situation in the middle of October. According to Van der Ham the Concertzender makes a positive community contribution, with “exceptional programming of serious music which is not available from other public radio stations.”

Many thanks to all those who did throw their support behind the campaign to keep Concertzender online. The match is not over yet, but it looks like it could be a good result. More proof that blogging is doing it for our time.

Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

Classical music roller coaster

Here is the Zurich Chamber Orchestra putting the usual YouTube offerings to shame. The full screen version is even better.

Zurich Chamber Orchestra : Roller Coaster
by mikropikol

More innovative classical music marketing from Switzerland here.
Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

A global classical music community?


My site traffic analysis shows that the enforced closure of Dutch classical music webcaster Concertzender was the big music news story over the weekend. As American expatriate composer Vanessa Lann lamented, the station closure is ‘very, very bad for Holland (and the rest of the international listening public)’ and as Dutch blogger Rolf Otterhouse wrote, the internet broadcaster is ‘an innovative and enthusiast team… with a passion for classical, contemporary, jazz and world music’. Despite this there has been little interest in the fate of Concertzender outside Europe, and, to date, I haven’t seen one US music blog run the story. I wonder if the coverage would have been different had an American classical music station been axed?

Update 17/11 - Dutch Culture Minister halts Concertzender closure.

More music beyond borders here.
Header image is geographic plot of all Overgrown Path readers as I write the story at 3.30pm UK time - Californians are in bed, lucky people. Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

Does the sound matter anymore?


A visit to the Norwegian website Hifiisentralen prompts me to ask, does the sound matter any more? Hifiisentralen linked to my recent Radka Toneff post, and I noticed that many of the comments on the Norwegian site included details of the member’s audio system. Blogs today are full of mentions of MP3s, iTunes, SACD, 5.1 and other miraculous acronyms. But when did you last see any discussion of the other links in the audio chain - the amplifier and loudspeakers?

A while back hi-fi brands such as Quad and Acoustic Research were mentioned as frequently as record labels and recording artists. It could be that audio systems are so good today that we don’t need to talk about them anymore. Or, it could be that we are so obsessed with storage and transmission media that we have forgotten the other vitally important components.

Personally, I tend to the latter explanation. It is a simple law of physics that you need large speakers to reproduce extended bass. And I’m not only talking about for listening to organ recitals. As I write the new Simax CD of George Crumb’s Makrokosmos I-II with pianist Ellen Ugelvik plays. Crumb’s music just doesn’t make sense unless you can physically experience the visceral quality of the sound, and you need serious loudspeakers to do that. Yet, much listening today is done on PC speakers, or even worse in-ear headphones that are prevented, again by the laws of physics, from reproducing the soundstage in front of the listener lovingly created by the recording engineer. Strange when concert hall acoustics are a million dollar science.

Elsewhere there is evidence that content producers are confusing the medium and the message. So often ‘perfect sound’ digital recordings fail to match analogue alternatives from decades ago. While in the car a couple of weeks back I heard a Bach keyboard concerto recording bought in by the BBC from a Canadian broadcaster and aired in the Radio 3 afternoon ‘graveyard’ slot that should never have been allowed past the audition stage, both for sound and performance quality. Naxos has done many great things, but a thread here a while back asked whether they dumbed-down production standards. And one of my own webcasts included some unwanted ornamentations.

Perhaps the it’s time to start thinking about the sound as well as the file format. Remember who said ‘Music demands more from a listener than simply the possession of a tape-machine or a transistor radio’.

* For information the main Overgrown Path listening room has a front end of Thorens TD 125 turntable with SME Series IIIS tone arm and Audio-Technica AT-F3 cartridge, Denon TU-260 tuner and Arcam Alpha 9 CD player. The amplifier is an Arcam 10 with moving-coil phono card, and the speakers are Bowers & Wilkins Nautilus 803s. Sennheiser 580 headphones are also used. There is a mains conditioner constructed by our electronics graduate son to smooth the sometimes noisy rural electricity supply. The secondary audio systems in other rooms all put the emphasis on loudspeaker quality. Online sources are usually auditioned via KEF Q50s floor-standers in my study. The Thorens front-end can be seen in this article.

The Simax CD of George Crumb’s Makrokosmos I-II was purchased from Prelude Records. All audio equipment mentioned in this article was bought at retail price. Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

Save the alternative classical music station

Rolf Otterhouse is not taking the enforced closure of Concertzender in Holland lying down. More power to Rolf. Check out his website here, listen to Concertzender, while you can, here.

Update 17/11 - Dutch Culture Minister halts Concertzender closure.

Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

BBC - 794 miles for some sweet Stravinsky


I have written here of how the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra (BBCSSO) is currently one of the UK’s finest bands. The BBCSSO is based in Glasgow, as is BBC Scotland, as are some very fine radio presenters. But, for last night’s live relay from Glasgow of the BBCSSO playing Stravinsky and Rachmaninov, BBC Radio 3 chose to use London based classical-jock of the moment Petroc Trelawny (above) to present the concert. Even if we forget that the ubiquitous and cringe-inducing Trelawny is a prime reasons why Radio 3 is currently losing listeners there was a 794 mile round trip to Scotland and back at executive travel rates to present 115 minutes of music when perfectly good (OK I’ll say it, much better) local presenters were available. And the BBC complain about their license fee settlement.

* Update 16/11 - but it wasn’t necessary…
Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

Mrs Mahler - may I take my jacket off?


Alma Mahler (above) - the beautiful wife of composer Gustav, whose affairs with the painters Klimt and Kokoschka, and the architect Walter Gropius, were legendary - once invited him to play in her house. “It was extremely hot, and I said to her, ‘Mrs Mahler, may I take my jacket off?’ She said, ‘Mr Pressler, as far as I’m concerned, you can undress completely.’

Pianist and founder of the Beaux Arts Trio Menahem Pressler talking in today’s Guardian. Alma Mahler is captured in song here.
Header photo of Alma Mahler from University of Pennsylvania Library, Alma Mahler Werfel Collection. Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk

Plug pulled on classical music broadcaster


The Concertzender Radio heard last night (you wrote about it on the 8th of September) that they are being taken off the support of the Dutch Arts Broadcast system, so they are effectively going off the (internet) air. What a huge mistake. It is one of the few excellent sources of culture in this country. Once it’s gone, it will be a permanent blight on the Dutch artistic conscience.Very, very bad for Holland (and the rest of the international listening public).
Vanessa Lann

Here is the story from the Concertzender website:

On Thursday November 13th at 5:30pm, the chairman of the Concertzender Nederland organisation came to report to the employees and volunteers that the Dutch Public Broadcasting System (NPO) plans to pull the plug on the Concertzender. In the very near future, all funding will be cut.

In a studio in the MCO building in Hilversum, Bierman informed the employees and volunteers present that the NPO no longer considers the Concertzender suitable for the public broadcasting roster. The Concertzender is primarily interested in content – music – and not in the size of the audience. Despite over 135,000 Internet
listeners per month - and we’re not counting the listeners via the cable, Digitenne or RadioOnDemand – the NPO’s board of directors doesn’t consider the Concertzender to be a good fit with their radio strategy, which primarily targets market share.

We are hereby informing our 6,000 donateurs, 125 volunteers, and thousands of interested parties and collaborators in the music sector of their decision. The music sector will be very interested to hear about this. For it will have an impact there as well. The Concertzender records around 250 concerts every year and support and promotes musical innovation. We have received masses of letters of support from all over the world (see http://czmoetblijven.blogspot.com for examples).

The future? It’s uncertain. The Concertzender hopes to continue to fulfill its role as a music broadcaster by and for the music sector. Without NPO financing, if necessary, although we feel that the Concertzender is exactly the kind of broadcaster that the public broadcasting system was designed to include. We would therefore welcome a continued role within the NPO, but one that acknowledges the identity and value of the Concertzender as a whole.

Update 17/11 - Dutch Culture Minister halts Concertzender closure.

Update 16/11 - more on the Concertzender closure here and here.

Here is an example of a contemporary Dutch composer’s courage.
Any copyrighted material on these pages is included as “fair use”, for the purpose of study, review or critical analysis only, and will be removed at the request of copyright owner(s). Report broken links, missing images and errors to - overgrownpath at hotmail dot co dot uk